Home » About Our Agency »
At Midwest Select Insurance Group (MSIG), we believe better insurance decisions start with better options. That is why we work with respected regional and national insurance carriers to provide dependable coverage solutions for businesses, families, employers, and individuals throughout Wisconsin.
Unlike captive agencies that represent only a single provider, our independent insurance agency model allows us to compare multiple insurance companies, evaluate coverage differences, and help clients explore policies that align with their needs, budgets, and long-term goals.
From commercial insurance and employee benefits to personal insurance and Medicare planning, our experienced team can provide guidance designed to simplify the process while delivering protection clients can rely on.
The Advantage of Working with an Independent Insurance Agency
Insurance is not one-size-fits-all. Every insurance company approaches pricing, underwriting, claims handling, and risk evaluation differently. The carrier that works well for one business or family may not provide the right protection for another.
That is where MSIG delivers value.
As an independent insurance agency, our team works on behalf of our clients. We focus on helping clients understand their options, identify coverage gaps, and compare policies from multiple carriers to make informed decisions with confidence. Our team is constantly staying up to date on carrier coverage changes and looking for new carriers to add to our growing list of 80+ companies.
Benefits of Choosing MSIG
- Access to dozens of top-rated insurance carriers
- Competitive pricing and policy comparisons
- Local guidance from experienced insurance professionals
- Ongoing policy reviews as clients’ needs evolve
- Experienced claims assistance and support
- Industry-specific insurance expertise
Our goal is to build long-term relationships by helping clients secure reliable protection backed by trusted insurance companies.
Commercial Insurance Carriers for Wisconsin Businesses
We work with established commercial carriers to help Wisconsin businesses with coverage solutions for general liability insurance, commercial property insurance, workers’ compensation, commercial auto insurance, and much more. Here are some of our trusted commercial companies:
Acuity Insurance
A highly respected Midwest carrier recognized for strong commercial insurance programs, including options for contractors and habitational risks.
Auto-Owners Insurance
Offers commercial property and liability insurance solutions, including options for auto service/repair shops and rental properties.
Cincinnati Insurance
A versatile carrier equipped to handle a wide range of business risks, specializing in lessors’ risk, retail, manufacturing, healthcare, and more.
Hanover
Provides commercial insurance programs to many business classes and operational risks, including professional services and cyber liability.
Philadelphia Insurance Companies
Recognized for niche industry expertise and commercial insurance programs, including human and social services.
Progressive Commercial
Frequently selected for commercial auto, transportation, and fleet insurance coverage.
SFM Mutual Insurance
Specializes in workers’ compensation insurance and workplace safety programs for employers.
Society Insurance
Offers commercial insurance solutions designed for bars, restaurants, delis, cafes, gas stations, and more.
Travelers
Provides broad commercial insurance capabilities for businesses ranging from small operations to large organizations.
West Bend Insurance
Known for reliable customer service and robust protection for businesses across multiple industries.
Trusted Home & Auto Insurance Companies
Wisconsin families and individuals can explore personal insurance options, like homeowners’ insurance, seasonal & vacation insurance, auto insurance, and more, to find dependable, value-driven protection. These are some of the many established home and auto providers we work with:
Acuity Insurance
Delivers personal insurance backed by Midwest experience and local agency partnerships.
Auto-Owners Insurance
Known for dependable home and auto insurance solutions, including options available for cabins and secondary homes.
Geico
Provides widely recognized insurance solutions, including coverage options for auto and recreational vehicles.
Ohio Mutual
Provides home, auto, and liability insurance solutions for a wide range of households and lifestyles.
Progressive
Offers competitive rates and flexible coverage options from auto coverage to boats, campers, and more.
Selective
Provides broad personal insurance solutions with protection choices for homeowners, drivers, and high-end estates.
West Bend Insurance
A respected regional carrier recognized for quality service and policyholder support.
Employee Benefits Insurance Partners
From group health insurance plans and dental insurance to employee enrollment support, Wisconsin businesses can compare dependable employee benefits solutions to meet their unique needs with MSIG. Along with many more, our carriers include:
Anthem
Provides national healthcare experience and robust group benefit solutions.
HealthPartners
Known for regional expertise and employer-focused health plan offerings.
Medica
Provides health insurance options for employers, families, and individuals across multiple markets.
Network Health
Regional health plan provider with a strong Midwest presence and community focus.
Security Health Plan
Wisconsin-based health insurance carrier providing strong local provider access.
UnitedHealthcare
Offers provider networks and flexible employer health insurance plans.
WPS Health Insurance
Established Wisconsin insurer that can offer employer and individual health coverage solutions.
Supplemental, Life & Disability Insurance Protection
To enhance traditional coverage, individuals and employers can add supplemental insurance options, including individual & group life insurance, vision, disability income protection, and more. Some of the multiple supplemental, life, and disability insurance companies we represent include:
Delta Dental
Widely recognized for dependable dental coverage solutions for employers and individuals.
Guardian
Provides dental, life, disability, and ancillary insurance programs.
Lincoln Financial
Specializes in life, disability, and retirement-related insurance products.
MetLife
A nationally recognized provider of life insurance and workplace benefits coverage.
Mutual of Omaha
Offers supplemental insurance and life insurance solutions for individuals and businesses.
Principal
Offers employee benefits and financial protection solutions for businesses and employees.
The Hartford
Provides employer-focused disability and ancillary insurance programs.
Unum
Focused on disability insurance and income protection programs for employees.
Individual Health Insurance & Medicare Guidance
Health insurance and Medicare decisions can often feel confusing, especially when comparing plans, provider networks, prescription coverage, and enrollment timelines.
MSIG can help individuals and retirees navigate available options with experienced guidance and local support, and can assist with:
- Individual Health Insurance Plans (Marketplace Coverage)
- Medicare Advantage Plans
- Medicare Supplement Insurance
- Prescription Drug Plans
- Life Insurance Solutions
- Annual Medicare Plan Reviews
- Enrollment Assistance & Education
Rather than limiting clients to one provider, our responsive and knowledgeable team can assist you in comparing multiple insurance companies to help identify plans that align with individual healthcare needs and budgets.
Find The Right Insurance Company with Confidence
Choosing insurance coverage is often one of the most important financial decisions individuals or businesses can make. Having access to multiple insurance carriers can allow clients to compare options, strengthen protection, and make decisions with greater confidence.
Here at MSIG, we work to combine carrier flexibility, industry experience, and industry-aligned service to help Wisconsin businesses and families secure insurance solutions designed for long-term protection and peace of mind. Whether reviewing business insurance, personal coverage, employee benefits, or Medicare options, our team is ready to help clients explore the right solutions for their future.
Contact Us
As an independent agency, we are here to help you find the right coverage.
